Statamic, Strapi and WordPress compared, and what we chose
A content management system (CMS) is a choice for years. It decides how your team edits content, what the website can connect to and how much maintenance it needs over time.
In this article we compare three well-known systems: Statamic, Strapi and WordPress. Each one fits a different kind of project. At the end, we explain which one we build on and why.
Statamic: a CMS built on Laravel
By default, Statamic stores content in files instead of a database. Those files can live in version control along with the code; a database is optional. Statamic is built on Laravel, a widely used PHP framework, so everything Laravel can do is available inside the website. For sites with multiple editors you need the Pro version, which has a license fee per site.
Content editing: The control panel is clear and is set up per site, so editors only see the fields they need.
Flexibility: Content structures and templates are fully configurable. Larger custom features are written in Laravel, in the same project.
Community and ecosystem: Smaller than that of WordPress, but active. Because Laravel is underneath, the wider Laravel ecosystem is available too.
Performance: Pages don't need a database query for their content, and static caching is built in. That keeps pages fast.
Learning curve: Low for editors. Developers need to know PHP and Laravel.
Good fit for: Websites and portals that connect to other systems, or that run on the same data as an internal application.
Strapi: headless and built on Node.js
As a headless CMS, Strapi only handles content management. It delivers content through an API (REST or GraphQL), and a separate frontend displays it: a website built with a JavaScript framework, for example, or a mobile app. Strapi runs on Node.js and is open source. There are also paid plans and a hosted version.
Content editing: The admin panel is clear. Editors work apart from the website itself, because the presentation lives in another application.
Flexibility: Content types and their APIs are easy to define. The same content can feed a website, an app and other channels.
Community and ecosystem: Smaller than that of WordPress, but active, with its own marketplace for plugins.
Performance: Good at serving content through an API. How fast the site feels depends largely on the frontend built on top of it.
Learning curve: Moderate. You build and maintain two parts, the CMS and the frontend, and the team needs to know JavaScript.
Good fit for: Projects where content goes to several channels, and teams that already work in JavaScript.
WordPress: the largest ecosystem
With its themes and plugins, WordPress is the most widely used CMS. It runs on PHP and MySQL. There's a plugin for almost every feature, and many developers and hosting companies know it well. The other side: every plugin is code from another party that has to be kept up to date, and a site with many plugins gets harder to maintain and to keep fast.
Content editing: The block editor is easy to learn, and many people have worked with it before.
Flexibility: Themes and plugins make a lot possible. Custom features beyond that take more effort and don't always fit the way WordPress is built.
Community and ecosystem: The largest of the three: lots of documentation, plugins and people who know it.
Performance: Fine for small and medium-sized sites. With many plugins or a lot of traffic, caching and optimization are needed.
Learning curve: Low. Even without a programming background, you can build and manage a site.
Good fit for: Sites with standard features that a team wants to manage largely by itself.
How to choose
The choice depends less on the system than on your project. Three questions help. Who edits the content, and how often? What does the website need to connect to? And who will maintain it five years from now?
WordPress fits a site with standard features that you largely manage yourself. Strapi fits when content goes to several channels and your team works in JavaScript. Statamic fits when the website connects to other systems, or needs custom features that have to be maintained for years.
Our choice: Laravel Statamic
At solutions.io we build websites on Laravel Statamic and web applications on Laravel. That choice follows from the kind of work we do.
Many of our projects are an internal system with a public side: a website, portal or webshop that runs on the same data. With Statamic, the website and the application share one foundation. One language, one way of working and one team that knows both. A connection to the internal system is ordinary Laravel code, not a plugin from another party.
Content stored in files is kept in version control along with the code. Every change can be traced, and an earlier version is easy to restore. And because we need few external add-ons, there's less to update and less that can break over the years.
That doesn't make Strapi or WordPress a bad choice. They fit other projects. Want to see what this looks like in practice? Our cases show what we've built, and you can always get in touch.